Skip to main content
Back to Blog

Medical Weight Loss Myths Our Patients Often Hear (And The Truth)

Updated: July 25, 2025

The Confusion is Real

We hear it all the time in our practice. Patients come in with their heads spinning from all the weight loss advice they've gotten from friends, family, and the internet. And honestly, who can blame them? There's so much conflicting information out there that it's hard to know what's actually true.

Actually, some of the most common things people believe about weight loss are just plain wrong. But these myths stick around because they sound logical or because someone's cousin's friend supposedly lost fifty pounds doing something crazy. The problem is, believing these myths can actually make losing weight harder – not easier.

So let's clear the air. We're going to tackle some of the biggest weight loss myths our patients bring up during their visits. Because when you understand what really works and what doesn't, you can stop wasting time on stuff that won't help.

Myth #1: All Calories Are Created Equal

This one drives us crazy because it sounds so reasonable. "A calorie is a calorie," people say. "Just eat less and move more." But your body doesn't work like a simple math equation.

The truth? Your body processes different types of calories in completely different ways. One hundred calories from a donut hit your system totally differently than one hundred calories from chicken breast. The donut spikes your blood sugar, triggers insulin release, and often leaves you hungrier than before. The protein, on the other hand, helps stabilize your blood sugar and keeps you feeling full.

And here's something most people don't know – your body actually burns more calories just digesting protein compared to carbs or fats. It's called the thermic effect of food, and it means that not all calories have the same impact on your metabolism.

Myth #2: You Have to Exercise for Hours Every Day

We see patients who think they need to become marathon runners overnight. They tell us they're planning to hit the gym for two hours every morning before work. And we just shake our heads because we know how this story ends.

Actually, you don't need to exercise for hours to lose weight. In fact, doing too much too fast is one of the quickest ways to burn out and quit altogether. Your body needs time to adapt, and your schedule needs to be realistic.

The real truth about exercise and weight loss might surprise you. While exercise is great for your health and can help with weight loss, what you eat matters way more than how much you exercise. You simply can't out-run a bad diet. We tell our patients that weight loss happens in the kitchen, and exercise is just the cherry on top.

Myth #3: Carbs Are the Enemy

Thanks to all the low-carb diet trends, carbs have gotten a really bad reputation. Patients come in convinced they need to cut out all bread, pasta, and fruit forever. But that's not how it works.

Your body actually needs carbohydrates to function properly. Your brain runs on glucose, which comes from carbs. The trick isn't avoiding all carbs – it's choosing the right ones and eating them at the right times.

Simple carbs like white bread and candy cause blood sugar spikes that can trigger cravings and fat storage. But complex carbs like vegetables, fruits, and whole grains provide steady energy and important nutrients. Even timing matters – eating carbs earlier in the day when you're more active usually works better than loading up on them at dinner.

Myth #4: Supplements Are Magic Bullets

Walk into any pharmacy and you'll see shelves full of weight loss supplements promising quick results. Our patients often ask us about the latest pill or powder they saw advertised online. And we get it – wouldn't it be nice if losing weight was as simple as taking a supplement?

But here's the reality check. Most weight loss supplements don't work, and the ones that do have some effect usually provide very modest results. There's no magic pill that's going to melt away pounds while you sleep or eat whatever you want.

The supplement industry isn't regulated like prescription medications, so companies can make pretty bold claims without much proof. We've seen patients spend hundreds of dollars on supplements that do absolutely nothing except drain their wallets.

Myth #5: Eating Fat Makes You Fat

This myth has been around forever, and it's probably one of the most damaging ones we encounter. Patients tell us they're afraid to eat nuts, avocados, or olive oil because they think dietary fat automatically becomes body fat. But that's not how your body works at all.

Actually, healthy fats are essential for weight loss and overall health. Your body needs fat to absorb certain vitamins, produce hormones, and keep your brain functioning properly. And here's the kicker – eating the right kinds of fat can actually help you lose weight by keeping you satisfied longer and reducing cravings.

The real problem isn't fat itself. It's the combination of refined carbs and unhealthy fats found in processed foods. Think donuts, cookies, and fried foods. These foods mess with your blood sugar and trigger your body to store fat more easily.

We encourage our patients to include healthy fats like those found in fish, nuts, seeds, and olive oil. These foods help stabilize blood sugar and keep hunger at bay between meals.

Myth #6: You Can Spot-Reduce Fat

"I just want to lose belly fat" or "Can you help me get rid of these arm flaps?" We hear this constantly. Everyone has that one area they want to target, and the fitness industry loves to sell the dream of spot reduction with special exercises or gadgets.

But your body doesn't work that way. You can't choose where you lose fat first, just like you can't choose where you gain it. When you lose weight, your body decides where the fat comes off, and it's usually not where you want it to happen first.

The good news? If you stick with a solid weight loss plan, you will eventually lose fat from those problem areas. It just takes patience and consistency. And those "targeted" exercises? They can help build muscle in specific areas, which can improve how those areas look once the fat comes off.

Myth #7: Slow Metabolism Means You're Doomed

We have patients who swear their metabolism is broken. They tell us they eat like a bird and still can't lose weight, while their skinny friend eats pizza all day and never gains a pound. And while metabolism does vary between people, it's probably not as broken as you think.

True metabolic disorders are actually pretty rare. More often, what people think is a slow metabolism is really just the result of years of yo-yo dieting, not eating enough protein, or losing muscle mass. The good news is that most of these issues can be fixed with the right approach.

Your metabolism isn't set in stone. You can boost it by building muscle, eating enough protein, getting quality sleep, and managing stress. Medical weight loss programs can also help identify and address any underlying issues that might be affecting your metabolism.

Myth #8: You Have to Be Perfect All the Time

This might be the most harmful myth of all. Patients come in thinking they need to follow their plan perfectly 100% of the time, and when they inevitably have a slip-up, they throw in the towel completely. It's all-or-nothing thinking, and it kills more weight loss efforts than anything else.

Real life happens. You're going to have birthday parties, work dinners, and stressful days when you don't make the best choices. That's not failure – that's being human. The key is getting back on track quickly instead of using one bad meal as an excuse to give up for the week.

We tell our patients that consistency beats perfection every time. Making good choices 80% of the time will get you much better results than trying to be perfect for two weeks and then giving up.

The Bottom Line: Medical Weight Loss Works

Here's what we've learned after helping thousands of patients lose weight: sustainable weight loss isn't about following the latest fad or believing internet myths. It's about understanding how your body actually works and creating a plan that fits your real life.

Medical weight loss programs work because they're based on science, not marketing hype. We can help you navigate all the conflicting information out there and create a personalized plan that actually makes sense for your body and your lifestyle.

And unlike trying to figure it out on your own, you'll have support every step of the way. We can help you understand what's working, what isn't, and how to adjust your approach when you hit plateaus or challenges.

If you're tired of believing myths and ready to start your real weight loss journey, we're here to help. Most major insurance plans cover medical weight loss programs, and our team at PrimeHealthMD can help you understand your eligibility and get started. Contact our practice today to learn how we can help you separate fact from fiction and finally achieve the lasting results you've been looking for, and find out if your insurance will cover your weight loss journey.

Contact Us

Schedule your appointment with Prime Health MD. Contact us for personalized healthcare services including weight loss, hormone optimization, and functional medicine.

Happy Couple